Skip to main content

First de facto offshore default for a Chinese SOE since 1998

Posted :

Updated :

Fiona Cheung

Fiona Cheung

Head of Credit - Asia

On 25 November 2019, Tewoo Group, a commodity trading company owned by the Tianjin municipal government, revealed a debt restructuring plan for US$1.25 billion of bonds1. The programme offers bondholders a choice: suffer losses of up to 64% or accept delayed repayments. The announcement marks the first de facto default for a Chinese state-owned enterprise (SOEs) in the offshore US dollar bond market since 19982. In this investment note, Fiona Cheung, Head of Credit, Asia, explains the significance of Tewoo’s de facto default and examines the broader implications for investors in Asian credits.

 

In our view, Tewoo’s defacto default resulted from the interaction of three factors: (1) the company’s weak standalone credit profile with high leverage, (2) the lack of strategic importance of Tewoo’s commodity-trading business; and (3) the Tianjin municipal government’s relatively high level of debt when compared with other tier-one Chinese cities.

The weak standalone credit profile of Tewoo means that the company must rely on bailouts from its state backers to survive. However, the Tianjin municipal government has limited incentive/capacity to provide support given the lack of strategic importance of Tewoo’s business and its own high debt level.

Unsustainably low default rates

Looking at the broader implications, the potential for defaults in China’s credit markets remains a hot topic among investors. The onshore default rate for Chinese SOE bonds has remained below 0.3% for the past few years despite high leverage3.The depressed rate was mainly due to implicit support claims from the government. Our long-term view is that such levels are not sustainable. Therefore, both central and local government authorities will be more selective when providing bailouts for financially-troubled SOEs in the future, especially during rough patches of economic growth. As such, our robust credit research process does not take claims of government ownership and implicit support for granted.

Moving forward, we believe that government support will be increasingly selective given the sheer number of SOEs – a decision driven by the associated moral hazard and the authorities’ increasing proclivity to allow troubled or unviable companies to fail and let investors take losses.

Which factors underpin government support for SOEs

When evaluating claims of implicit government support, we assess two principal issues: is the SOE’s business strategically important to the economy, and will the default have a systemic impact or lead to potential contagion. We also look at several other aspects relating to the company’s overall financial health, as well as the willingness and ability of the central/provincial/local government to offer assistance. Broadly speaking, we prefer SOEs that provide essential or critical services in contrast to those operating in highly competitive industries, a commoditised business line or dealing with financial investments.

 

1 Bloomberg, 25 November 2019.

2 Bloomberg, 26 November 2019.

3 Goldman Sachs, as of 18 October 2019.

 

Market & Investment Economic and market implications for oil prices Read more
Market & Investment A framework for navigating a massive uncertainty shock Read more
Market & Investment The Fed’s rate decision: Not so surprising, but what’s the path forward? Read more
Market & Investment In focus: U.S. inflationary forces Read more
Market & Investment Market note: The Fed strikes a dovish tone Read more
Market & Investment Global Healthcare: Enhanced innovation in a post-COVID environment Read more
Market & Investment With Fed easing potentially on hold, what does this mean for fixed-income investors? Read more
Market & Investment The fog of uncertainty has thickened Read more
Market & Investment Food price inflation: 10 implications Read more
Market & Investment Hong Kong/Mainland China market update Read more
Market & Investment Positioning in the looming stagflation environment Read more
Market & Investment Q&A with the Portfolio Manager: Global Healthcare Equities Read more
Market & Investment From coronavirus to credit market stress Read more
Market & Investment Flight of the Doves Read more
Market & Investment Global Healthcare: Spotlight continues to shine on the sector Read more
Market & Investment The impact of coronavirus on Chinese equities Read more
Market & Investment Market Note - G20 Meeting Recap: Seven Macro Takeaways Read more
Market & Investment How is the surging US dollar affecting Asian currencies? Read more
Market & Investment Manulife Philippines Continues to Advance Impact Agenda with Sustainability and Community Efforts | Manulife Investments Philippines Read more
Market & Investment India Equity Thought Leadership: Transitioning to India’s next stage of growth Read more
Market & Investment In Focus: The Russia-Ukraine crisis could bring global impact and spillover effects Read more
Market & Investment How should investors approach the upcoming U.S. election? Read more
Market & Investment Assessing China’s latest stimulus measures Read more
Market & Investment Indian equities: Two powerful drivers propel long-term growth prospects Read more
Market & Investment Greater China Equities Q&A Read more
Market & Investment Global risk-off market sentiment prevails Read more
Market & Investment The potentially defensive properties of Asian equities Read more
Market & Investment The Age of AI: Economic Impact and the AI Investment Universe Read more
Market & Investment The potential impact of the US presidential election on Greater China equities Read more
Market & Investment Asian fixed income should take geopolitical events in its stride Read more
Market & Investment Transitioning to India’s next stage of growth Read more
Market & Investment Market Note - Tariff threat trips the circuit breaker, setting the scene for a 50 basis points Fed rate cut in September Read more
Market & Investment Southeast Asia — a bright spot in a challenging environment Read more
Market & Investment Q&A: The role of Asia-Pacific bonds in an investor’s portfolio Read more
Market & Investment Rising bond yields and market correction Read more
Market & Investment Three questions for the Fed in the lead-up to its March meeting Read more
Market & Investment Southeast Asia – vulnerable for now, but resilient over the longer term Read more
Market & Investment The Fed reiterates its hawkish bias Read more
Market & Investment The Russia-Ukraine crisis and its implications for EM Asia and China Read more
Market & Investment China’s policy tailwinds set economic recovery in motion Read more
Market & Investment Asian Fixed Income: Seizing the opportunity Read more
Market & Investment Asia-Pacific (ex-Japan) equities: Strategic opportunities amid a diverging landscape Read more
Market & Investment Banking stress has created a yield premium for preferred securities Read more
Market & Investment Coronavirus update - A material economic reassessment Read more
Market & Investment China’s double pivot — A major shift in China’s COVID and property sector policies Read more
Market & Investment China credit watch: First de facto offshore default for a Chinese SOE since 1998 Read more
Market & Investment China and Hong Kong equity markets tested by a “perfect storm” Read more
Market & Investment Thoughts from macrostrategy team – Coronavirus: What does it mean for investors? Read more
Market & Investment China rolls out measures to support economic growth Read more
Market & Investment Assessing the contagion risk from ongoing banking concerns to Asia Read more
Market & Investment Preferred securities: From active management to sustainable investing Read more
Market & Investment AP-REITs: Resilience amid strong fundamentals Read more
Market & Investment Asia Pacific REITs - Long-term fundamentals should not be overshadowed by short-term flux Read more
Market & Investment Manulife Asia Pacific REIT Fund of Funds Read more
Market & Investment Multi-asset income: in pursuit of higher yields in a low growth world Read more
Market & Investment Did markets overreact to January’s U.S. inflation data? Read more
Market & Investment Long-term structural strengths and resilience of Indian economy to continue despite cyclical challenges Read more
Market & Investment Monetary tightening amid heightened uncertainty: implications for emerging markets Read more
Market & Investment An income-oriented solution in a higher-yielding environment Read more
Market & Investment The Impact of US Tariffs on Indian Exports Read more
Market & Investment Q&A: Potential market impact of a US government shutdown Read more
Market & Investment Bank failures—unexpected events make investment decisions difficult Read more
Market & Investment Global Healthcare Equities Q&A Read more
Market & Investment The pause before the pivot: positioning bond portfolios for an evolving policy landscape Read more
Market & Investment Market note: Latest tariff threat could derail a Sino-US trade deal Read more
Market & Investment Making Sense of the Market Rebound Read more
Market & Investment Macro anchors shaping the global growth outlook Read more
Market & Investment The Fed remains hawkish, but easing could occur before the end of 2023 Read more
Market & Investment US inflation outlook Read more
Market & Investment Vaccine for COVID-19: Is the wait finally over? Read more
Market & Investment Why China's rising tide may not lift EM boats Read more
Market & Investment Quick thoughts on US reciprocal tariffs Read more
Market & Investment What does a strong U.S. dollar mean for global growth? Read more
Market & Investment Quick comments on Moody's cut US credit rating Read more
Market & Investment US interest-rate cut Read more
Market & Investment Solutions for navigating market volatility amid U.S. tariff changes Read more
Market & Investment US-China phase-one trade deal - the devil is in the details Read more
Market & Investment Will the Fed's approach to interest-rate hikes trigger a U.S. recession? Read more
Market & Investment US economic outlook: macroeconomic headwinds vs. tailwinds Read more
US election - What’s next for Asian markets? Read more
Market & Investment US dollar outlook - moving from strength to weakness Read more
Market & Investment US China trade agreement, UK election, Fed easing - stronger base case, but risks remain Read more
Market & Investment Why Asia is likely to escape the global inflation scare Read more
Market & Investment US-China trade war - A framework for thinking about new tariffs Read more
Market & Investment How can multi-asset investing help today's income-seekers? Read more
Market & Investment Asian Short Duration Bonds: One of the ways to put your cash to work Read more
Market & Investment Here come the tariffs: why it’s too soon to draw conclusions Read more
Market & Investment After elections: What’s next for India? Read more
Market & Investment Asian equities: opportunities in a diverging market landscape Read more
Market & Investment Investment note - Sino-US Trade tensions enter a new phase Read more
Market & Investment After four interest-rate hikes, what will the Fed do next? Read more
Market & Investment Market Note - The Fed’s next chapter: this is no regular interest-rate cut Read more
Market & Investment Beyond the Fed’s hawkish “pause”: three macro elements to consider Read more
Market & Investment The FED's historic stimulus package Read more
Market & Investment Financial markets and the U.S. election Read more
Market & Investment Emergency interest-rate cuts are here Read more
Market & Investment A “hawkish pause” signal from the Fed Read more
Market & Investment Navigating the regulatory environment for China equities Read more
Market & Investment The Fed starts easing: Potential tailwinds for high-quality US credits Read more
Market & Investment The implications of recent trade policies on Greater China equities Read more
Market & Investment Fed’s first rate cut of 2025: Implications & takeaways Read more
Market & Investment How might the US election and China’s stimulus package impact Asian fixed income? Read more
Market & Investment Regional bank failures create potential risks and opportunities for investors Read more
Market & Investment Beyond the hyperbole: three macro takeaways from the 2024 US elections Read more